Making your activism accessible: Difference between revisions
Line 63: | Line 63: | ||
*Sometimes approaches to climate can reinforce ableism, and this is represented by the term eco-ableism. See our page on [[ableism]] for examples of eco-ableism | *Sometimes approaches to climate can reinforce ableism, and this is represented by the term eco-ableism. See our page on [[ableism]] for examples of eco-ableism | ||
{| class="wikitable" style="font-size: 14.4px; width: 100%; height: 364px; border-color: rgb(0, 0, 0);" | {| class="wikitable" style="font-size: 14.4px; width: 100%; height: 364px; border-color: rgb(0, 0, 0);" | ||
|- style="height: 55px;" | |- style="height: 55px;" | ||
| style="width: 21.7495%; background-color: #c51f84; border-color: #000000; height: 55px;" | | | style="width: 21.7495%; background-color: #c51f84; border-color: #000000; height: 55px;" | | ||
Line 86: | Line 86: | ||
| style="width: 78.2137%; height: 28px;" | *The structural barriers that disability communities face become a matter of life or death during disaster. Thus, people with disabilities are 5 times more likely to die in a natural disaster. -[https://greenisthenewblack.com/disability-rights-is-a-climate-justice-issue-heres-why/ Leanne McNulty ] | | style="width: 78.2137%; height: 28px;" | *The structural barriers that disability communities face become a matter of life or death during disaster. Thus, people with disabilities are 5 times more likely to die in a natural disaster. -[https://greenisthenewblack.com/disability-rights-is-a-climate-justice-issue-heres-why/ Leanne McNulty ] | ||
*"When we aren’t included before disaster strikes, how will we be effectively accommodated during a crisis? When disability is an afterthought, or something squeezed into an existing response plan, risk is created that could have been planned for and perhaps avoided."-[https://ssir.org/articles/entry/climate_change_environmental_activism_and_disability Daphne Frias] for Stanford Social Innovation Review (e.g. evacuation plans, access to cooling centers etc).<br> | *"When we aren’t included before disaster strikes, how will we be effectively accommodated during a crisis? When disability is an afterthought, or something squeezed into an existing response plan, risk is created that could have been planned for and perhaps avoided."-[https://ssir.org/articles/entry/climate_change_environmental_activism_and_disability Daphne Frias] for Stanford Social Innovation Review (e.g. evacuation plans, access to cooling centers etc).<br> | ||
* [https://wid.org/2018/09/26/climate-related-migration/ Climate change is accelerating forced migration] at a time when disabled people find it increasingly difficult to cross borders — not simply because of the physical demands, but also because of political opposition. Disabled people may be unable to enter countries because their diagnosis or condition is considered 'burdensome'. -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] | * "[https://wid.org/2018/09/26/climate-related-migration/ Climate change is accelerating forced migration] at a time when disabled people find it increasingly difficult to cross borders — not simply because of the physical demands, but also because of political opposition." Disabled people may be unable to enter countries because their diagnosis or condition is considered 'burdensome'. -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] Plus, migrants may struggle to access the services they need (health services and long-term medical, financial, and social support). -[https://rootedinrights.org/its-time-to-recognize-climate-change-as-a-disability-rights-issue/ Tiffany Yu] | ||
Specific examples include: | Specific examples include: | ||
*"Some members of the disability community are especially vulnerable to extreme heat events due to increased sensitivity to keeping our body temperatures cool enough." | *"Some members of the disability community are especially vulnerable to extreme heat events due to increased sensitivity to keeping our body temperatures cool enough." -[https://rootedinrights.org/its-time-to-recognize-climate-change-as-a-disability-rights-issue/ Tiffany Yu] | ||
*Natural disaster can cut electricity, "which is especially problematic because so many disabled people need electricity-powered medical equipment to survive." | *Natural disaster can cut electricity, "which is especially problematic because so many disabled people need electricity-powered medical equipment to survive." -[https://rootedinrights.org/its-time-to-recognize-climate-change-as-a-disability-rights-issue/ Tiffany Yu] | ||
*Droughts and flooding cause food and water insecurity. "Because of other social factors like the[https://disablepoverty.org/what-is-disable-poverty/ disproportionate number of disabled people who are caught in an endless poverty cycle], the disability community is especially vulnerable during these shortages." | *Droughts and flooding cause food and water insecurity. "Because of other social factors like the[https://disablepoverty.org/what-is-disable-poverty/ disproportionate number of disabled people who are caught in an endless poverty cycle], the disability community is especially vulnerable during these shortages." -[https://rootedinrights.org/its-time-to-recognize-climate-change-as-a-disability-rights-issue/ Tiffany Yu] | ||
*Disabled people may be unable to evacuate from disaster and/or may lose "critical mobility and accessibility devices (wheelchairs, scooters, walkers, canes, hearing aids, communication devices)." | *Disabled people may be unable to evacuate from disaster and/or may lose "critical mobility and accessibility devices (wheelchairs, scooters, walkers, canes, hearing aids, communication devices)." -[https://rootedinrights.org/its-time-to-recognize-climate-change-as-a-disability-rights-issue/ Tiffany Yu] | ||
|- style="height: 51px;" | |- style="height: 51px;" | ||
| style="width: 21.7495%; background-color: #c51f84; border-color: #000000; height: 51px;" | | | style="width: 21.7495%; background-color: #c51f84; border-color: #000000; height: 51px;" | | ||
Line 108: | Line 108: | ||
| style="width: 21.7495%; background-color: #c51f84; border-color: #000000; height: 51px;" | '''<span style="color: #ffffff;">'Survival of the fittest' is an oppressive mindset</span>''' | | style="width: 21.7495%; background-color: #c51f84; border-color: #000000; height: 51px;" | '''<span style="color: #ffffff;">'Survival of the fittest' is an oppressive mindset</span>''' | ||
| style="width: 78.2137%; height: 51px;" | | | style="width: 78.2137%; height: 51px;" | | ||
*Accepting the loss of some lives over others as 'inevitable' is oppressive. We aren't just talking about physical vulnerability; ableism, racism, class inequality and other forms of oppression work together to compound and intensify risk. | *Accepting the loss of some lives over others as 'inevitable' is oppressive. "We aren't just talking about physical vulnerability; ableism, racism, class inequality and other forms of oppression work together to compound and intensify risk." -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] | ||
*"Working for climate justice requires challenging the root causes of vulnerability, rather than treating disabled people as the inevitable casualties of climate change. It also means interrogating the realities that keep ''some of us'' farther from the storm." -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] | *"Working for climate justice requires challenging the root causes of vulnerability, rather than treating disabled people as the inevitable casualties of climate change. It also means interrogating the realities that keep ''some of us'' farther from the storm." -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] | ||
*Access to wealth makes it easier to evacuate, and white supremacy translates "into the political clout and communal resources that make climate disruptions more survivable in the first place — better infrastructure, [https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/toxic-wastes-and-race-at-twenty-1987-2007.pdf less exposure to environmental hazards] and more robust public assistance during and after crisis." -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] | *Access to wealth makes it easier to evacuate, and white supremacy translates "into the political clout and communal resources that make climate disruptions more survivable in the first place — better infrastructure, [https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/toxic-wastes-and-race-at-twenty-1987-2007.pdf less exposure to environmental hazards] and more robust public assistance during and after crisis." -[https://truthout.org/articles/disabled-people-cannot-be-expected-losses-in-the-climate-crisis/ Julia Watts Belser] |
Revision as of 19:02, 5 May 2023
This page was created to support activists in making their spaces more accessible, that is, to ensure everyone's needs to access movement spaces are met so more people can contribute to the climate movement in whatever way they can! Several of the topics found in this guide are based on questions asked by activists in the HUB's community (i.e. how to make in-person events more accessible, how to make promotional materials more engaging etc.).
The information included comes from existing organizer databases and resources by movement thinkers. We've included resources from blogs written by people living with accessibility needs, as they are experts on this topic. However, note that each personal experience is distinct, thus we encourage further insight from different positionalities to share further ideas on how this page can be expanded upon and improved. This guide includes definitions of accessibility, messaging suggestions on the intersections of climate and disability justice, considerations for accessible event, action planning, communication and content sharing, considerations for creating an accessible culture and other suggestions related to creating a space that is accessible to everyone who wants to contribute to the movement for climate justice.
Defining accessibility
"Universal accessibility is the character of a product, process, service, information or environment which, with a view to fairness and an inclusive approach, allows anyone to carry out activities independently and to obtain equivalent results." - Groupe DÉFI Accessibilité (GDA) [1] & Ex Aequo
Ex Aequo distinguish accessibility from adaptation: "Adaptation would consist of changes made in order to accommodate people in relation to “an environment, a communication, a program, or an already existing service. We adapt when we build a subway with only stairs, then add elevators several years later. We make it universally accessible when we provide access ramps to the buses."
Why is Accessibility Critical to Movement Spaces?
Access Culture expands on definitions of accessibility, explaining:
"For people who live on the margins, who have to fight to prove their existence, who are excluded from movements, who are subject to abuse in the form of isolation, having access to spaces means having access to community, to connection, to existence. When we make spaces accessible, when we build movements based on inclusion, we recognize that each person has an intrinsic value, that our existence is beautiful and necessary. Creating accessible spaces is about recognizing that connection is necessary, that community is necessary, that our culture is built on the myth of separation, the lie of disconnection. We must move from independence to interdependence in order to transform society."
Why is accessibility critical to movement spaces?
1. Embodying our values |
|
2. Prioritizing and leadership of marginalized people |
|
3. Meeting everyone’s needs to build our collective fight |
|
5. Organizers are burning out!/Non-disabled people are impacted by ableism too |
|
6. Disability justice is intersectionally related to all other fights for justice. |
|
As described by Aerik Woodams at People's Hub, individual access is often framed as extra work; that there are 'more important things to address'. Disabled and otherwise marginalized people ask us to do things differently. This might feel like work at first, but these efforts benefit all of us by giving us more strength, understanding and tools to build a better world.
Disability Justice is Climate Justice: Messaging Suggestions
- Sometimes approaches to climate can reinforce ableism, and this is represented by the term eco-ableism. See our page on ableism for examples of eco-ableism
Describing disability justice |
|
Disabled people are marginalized and are deserving of liberation |
|
Environmental racism and natural disasters cause disabilities |
|
Natural disasters disproportionately harm disabled and other marginalized people | *The structural barriers that disability communities face become a matter of life or death during disaster. Thus, people with disabilities are 5 times more likely to die in a natural disaster. -Leanne McNulty
Specific examples include:
|
Avoid eco-ableist messaging |
|
Address immediate survival needs |
Being concerned about and fighting for climate justice is a privilege." -Tiffany Yu |
'Survival of the fittest' is an oppressive mindset |
|
Holding Accessible Events and Meetings
Disability and able-bodies exist on a spectrum. Most of us have experience with ableism and the pressures of capitalism, and/or experience being excluded by other systems of oppression that limit our access. We invite you to reflect on how making a space accessible goes beyond ensuring people can physically access a space, but also that they can show up as fully as others in the room. If helpful, we suggest checking out our wiki on incorporating space watchers and holders for further considerations.
Quick tips:
- Pause frequently during events and meetings to ask if anyone has any access needs that need to be addressed!
- UK Mutual Aid has an example of an accessibility checklist that you can use as a blueprint to creating a checklist for your team.
Childcare |
|
Wheelchair accessibility |
Doors must be 800mm minimum.
|
Food and water |
|
Accessibility support |
|
Transportation |
|
Ways to participate |
|
Timing and barriers to participation |
|
Language |
|
Timing |
|
Allergies and sensitivities |
|
Photography |
|
Bathrooms |
|
Neurodivergent and/or introverted inclusion
|
Neurodivergent: describes how developmental disorders are normal variations in the brain. [6] The neurodiverse umbrella [7] includes but is not limited to ADHD, dyslexia, autism, and other learning disabilities. Many people also include mental illnesses under the umbrella of neurodiversity, such as anxiety, bipolar, PTSD, schizophrenia etc.
Meeting neurodivergent and introverted needs:
|
BIPOC inclusion [8] |
|
Gender identity inclusion [9] |
|
Low-income inclusion [10] |
|
Pandemic Safety Measures
If you do not have safety measures in place during a pandemic, higher-risk individuals in particular are unlikely to attend your event. It also sends the message that people at high-risk of becoming very ill are disposable. Safety measures prevent people from becoming seriously ill, long-term disability and death.
Thomas A. Russo, professor of Infectious disease at the University of Buffalo, suggests that safety measures to put in place when planning an in-person event include:
- Advertising that attendees wear masks for the duration of the event, even for events held outdoors. Have extra masks available for those who come without one, ideally N95 or KN95’s which are one of the best available options to protect against COVID-19.
- Have a few volunteers who can provide hand sanitizer every so often, and especially before distributing food if this is included in your event.
- State that those who are feeling ill, have come in contact with someone who has tested positive OR have come in contact with someone who has tested negative but is showing symptoms of illness, should not attend.
- Encourage attendees to keep their distance from one another as often as possible.
The People’s CDC has further recommendations for planning safe gatherings during a pandemic:
- Provide universal pre and post event testing.
- Stay in small, consistent groups.
- Perform contact tracing.
- Ensure the meeting space has adequate ventilation and air quality (open windows/doors, ensure HVAC systems are functional, use HEPA filters if possible).
- Perform high filtration universal masking. Provide certified N95/KN94 masks if possible.
- Provide a place for folks to eat outside.
- Reduce high-risk activities 5 days prior to the event (i.e. unmasked, indoor activities outside of the household)
- Gather outdoors when possible. The risk of catching an airborne virus from an outdoor gathering is lower than from an indoor one. There is still a risk of contracting a virus, especially at crowded protests or gatherings.
Suggestions for Virtual Events [11]
Internet access |
|
Invite and include disabled people and their needs |
Live descriptions, captions and good audio are key for live streamed events.
|
Share the format of the event and how long it plans to run |
|
Provide any written or visual materials ahead of time. |
|
Allow attendees to send questions and comments in advance. |
|
Build time for reflection/breaks into your event, as well as time for questions. |
|
Offer channels to provide feedback about the event |
|
Suggestions for Hybrid and Virtual Meetings
Virtual and hybrid virtual/in person meetings require stable internet connections, access to hardware (i.e. cell phones and computers) and some technology literacy.
If you’re working with participants who don’t have access to the internet or hardware, these tips may be hard to implement. However, there are other tools and techniques you can use such as conference call services, message groups, photos of call lists, etc. that can be used. The following are tips for holding hybrid (in-person and virtual) meetings, and general meeting tips.
Blueprints for Change offers an extensive guide filled with tips on hosting effective hybrid meetings. The following compiles some of the tips found in their hosting virtual/hybrid meetings guide, and from the write up developed by Training for Change.
Considerations for Planning a Hybrid Meeting
Things you'll need to do this successfully |
Those who join a meeting using their phone do not have the same functions available as those using a desktop. Consider sending important links ahead of the meeting, or in your workspace during, so people on the phone can access them.
|
Prepare ahead of time |
|
Roles you might consider when hosting hybrid meetings |
-Lead facilitator -Co-facilitator(s) -Bridge facilitator; to bridge the digital and IRL spaces and who can support the IRL facilitator to make sure the digital folks are supported. This person could also be assigned to keep track of participants who have asked for a speaking turn so that both in person and digital voices are included. -Visuals, Slides & Notes lead -Tech lead; to manage your session slides, doing things like screen sharing, watching the chat box, setting up and doing sound checks at the beginning of your session, and troubleshooting if problems come up along the way. -Vibes & Energizers lead -Stack keeper (monitor order of speakers, chat and Q&A functions) -Buddies for virtual participants (for hybrid meetings) |
Plan for shifts in power dynamics, because some people are in groups vs others are on their own. |
-People connecting in groups may have an easier time connecting with others in the same room. -People connecting on their own may have an easier time connecting with others who also connected on their own. -Those who connected the same way as the facilitator may have an easier time communicating with the facilitator. -When you use the chat box, those on their own device have easier access to participate. -When people are in a room together, those controlling the screen, who are on camera and/or closer to the microphone are advantaged. |
Preparing Participants Before the Meeting
Provide and seek information |
Information to provide/seek to prepare participants include:
|
Offer a training on how to use the platform |
|
Holding the Hybrid/Virtual Meetings
Start with introductions and a check-in. |
Let folks introduce themselves, their pronouns and make time for relationship building by letting people share how they are doing or something about them.
|
Try to take notes and video recordings for those who can't attend. |
|
Provide a person or place where attendees can seek support |
|
It might be relevant to share participation guidelines and/or the group's mission statement to ground the group before beginning. |
Examples of participation guidelines, inspired by Aspiration Tech [21] , might include...
|
Get participants to engage with one another! |
|
Use a circle up tool to keep participation equal | 1. Put all participants around one big virtual circle.
2. Mark a little check next to someone whenever they speak. You can also use a star or other symbol to track when each person shares during a specific activity. Have one person assigned to do this, and to let the facilitator know who deserves speaking time. See the example from Training for Change |
Be mindful of participants who may not be able to see or hear or otherwise fully participate in virtual meetings. | *If an attendee is blind, you should use more descriptive language that paints a picture of what others are seeing and provides richer context.
|
Closing Meetings
|
Creating Accessible Group Cultures
The following section drew from the writings of:
- Liz Kessler, a person who describes themselves as disabled and who is involved in struggles for justice [12]
- Lee, a disabled, queer, trans and autistic activist. [13]
Suggestions for fostering accessible group cultures:
Work with different abilities and limits |
|
Incorporate regular discussions about personal and group boundaries |
|
Plan break times |
|
Focus on content, rather than how something is said |
|
Uplift intersectional perspectives |
|
Finally, accept that building accessible group cultures is a process. There is no set finish line. We have to stay tuned and pay attention to the people around us.
Accessibility in Media and Materials
There are many things to consider when it comes to accessible communication. It is important to ensure our written material is easy to read, easy to understand, and make it easy to find the information you need and use the first time you read it.
General Guidelines for Accessible Written Materials [14] [15] [16]
Order, bolding and font |
|
Avoid jargon, abbreviations and technical terms |
|
Use as few words as possible |
|
Break up the text |
|
Use gender-neutral language |
|
Use accessible colour choices |
|
Web access |
|
Writing Image Descriptions [17]
Most important elements to describe:
Basic process for writing a description:
|
Accessible Audio and Video [18]
Add subtitles/captions
- Check out Accessible Social's step-by-step guide for adding captions/subtitles to videos!
Audio descriptions
- An audio description is a form of narration to support blind and low vision users.
- If audio descriptions are not available, written descriptions can be used. They are typically presented as written text that can be reviewed along with the video.See this example presenting the trailer for The Wheel of Time.
- An option for making videos with audio descriptions to create two versions of your video, one with an audio description integrated with the rest of your video’s audio and one without. Below is an example of an audio description.
Further resources
- People's hub offers trainings organizers on creating culture of access if folks are interested in further learning on this topic, and also a peer support space for people with chronic illness/disability to meet online.
- Disability Justice is Climate Justice (Sins Invalid)-Article and ASL video
Disability Rights is a Climate Justice Issue. Here’s Why (Leanne McNulty)-Article
To Survive Climate Catastrophe, Look to Queer & Disabled Folks (YES! Magazine)-Article
- The Rights of People with Disabilities in Disasters & Public Health Emergencies (World Institute of Disability)- List of resources
If you have any suggested revisions or additional resources to share related to the above content, please email them to kenzie@lehub.ca.
- ↑ Groupe DEFI Accessibilite (GDA) - Research report for associations in Montreal - Universal Accessibility and contributing designs (version 5.3), Langevin, Rocque, Chalghoumi & Ghorayeb, University of Montreal
- ↑ https://www.yesmagazine.org/opinion/2019/07/31/climate-change-queer-disabled-organizers
- ↑ https://www.un.org/development/desa/disabilities/resources/factsheet-on-persons-with-disabilities.html
- ↑ https://collectifau.ca/
- ↑ https://www.sinsinvalid.org/blog/access-suggestions-for-a-public-event
- ↑ https://www.webmd.com/add-adhd/features/what-is-neurodiversity
- ↑ https://instagram.com/p/CYBl-miPcCL/
- ↑ https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Bt6SVDG3DhqfCs0TDihFYdWK5Fc3TmsAVG4dqIZTueA/edit
- ↑ https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Bt6SVDG3DhqfCs0TDihFYdWK5Fc3TmsAVG4dqIZTueA/edit
- ↑ https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Bt6SVDG3DhqfCs0TDihFYdWK5Fc3TmsAVG4dqIZTueA/edit
- ↑ https://rootedinrights.org/how-to-make-your-virtual-meetings-and-events-accessible-to-the-disability-community/
- ↑ https://data.over-blog-kiwi.com/1/85/65/14/20180525/ob_91a56c_milieu-militant-inclusif-neurodivergen.pdf
- ↑ https://accessculture.wordpress.com/2012/07/06/how-to-be-an-ally-to-disabled-neurodiverse-folks-in-activist-academic-communities/
- ↑ https://www.plainlanguage.gov/guidelines/
- ↑ https://www.bdadyslexia.org.uk/advice/employers/creating-a-dyslexia-friendly-workplace/dyslexia-friendly-style-guide
- ↑ https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/
- ↑ https://antimonarchy.tumblr.com/post/635980711208386560/how-to-create-image-descriptions
- ↑ https://www.accessible-social.com/