Making your activism accessible: Difference between revisions
Line 226: | Line 226: | ||
|} | |} | ||
<p><span><span style="background-color: #d1f1ee;" >Holding Accessible Virtual Meetings</span></span></p> | |||
<p><span style="background-color: rgb(255, 255, 255);" ><span>Tips from Aspiration Tech's Evelyn Arellano<span> <ref> http://commonslibrary.org/power-dynamics-and-inclusion-in-virtual-meetings/</ref> </span></span></span></p> | |||
<p><span style="background-color: rgb(255, 255, 255);" ><span><span>Before the meeting:</span></span></span></p> | |||
*Schedule group meetings '''at least''' 2-3 days ahead of time. This helps members to arrange for schedules, care-taking, quiet space, tech, etc. | |||
*'''Provide context '''regarding the main agenda items before the meeting. For example, what is the main purpose and importance of the meeting? What are the meeting goals? | |||
*'''Request input and feedback''' from all who will be participating to add agenda items and confirm whether the meeting goals address their needs. Make sure those attending are clear on how time will be spent. | |||
*<span>Ask participants to share if they will need '''translation, interpretation, or any other accommodations. '''Ask if those who plan to participate need any '''assistance in setting up and learning the technology platforms used. '''Provide at least a few days for participants to inform you about their needs. </span> | |||
*<span>Provide '''items you want participants to review''' before or during the meeting ahead of time so folks can reflect before the meeting. </span> | |||
*<span>Mention if you will be recording ahead of time so folks can raise concerns if they have them.</span> | |||
<span>At the beginning of the meeting:</span> | |||
<span></span> | |||
*'''Start with introductions and a check-in. '''Let folks introduce themselves, their pronouns and make time for relationship building by letting people share how they are doing or something about them. For example, check-in questions related to care might be "what colour best describes how you're feeling today?" Or, "If you're comfortable, share one high and one low from your week so far!" You can also hold more fun get-to-know one another check-in's to lighten the mood of the meeting, such as "tell us about a book or tv show you engaged with recently that you'd recommend!" Or, "what is your favourite houseplant?"<br> | |||
*It might be relevant to come up with and '''share participation guidelines and/or the group's mission statement '''to ground the group before beginning.''' '''Some examples of participation guidelines, inspired by Aspiration Tech<span style="background-color: #ffffff;" ><span> <ref> http://commonslibrary.org/power-dynamics-and-inclusion-in-virtual-meetings/</ref> </span></span>, might include... | |||
**Please focus on listening, not only on what you are hearing. | |||
**Wherever possible, please refrain from multitasking on email or social media. Try to stay tuned in to what others are saying and feeling.<br> | |||
**Please use simple, accessible language. Please avoid jargon and acronyms. | |||
**When you speak, please try to make one point or a few brief points and then let others speak. We want everyone to have an equal chance to speak. <br> | |||
**Help us be mindful of the schedule and stay on time. Please support us in moving the dialog forward. | |||
**''''''Please indicate you want to speak by raising your hand on video; if you are not able to use or raise your hand, please feel free to speak up, but please try not to interrupt others. | |||
**Stay muted when you are not speaking. | |||
**Please be mindful of background noise and join the call from a quiet location if you can. Parents and caregivers are certainly exempt, but muting still applies. | |||
*Try to take''' notes and video recordings''' for those who can't attend. Name it early that you are recording and allow folks to opt out, by getting off video, or managing their participation. Plans to record should also be mentioned before the meeting so concerns can be addressed. | |||
*Provide a person or place where attendees can seek support if they feel disrespected or have needs that aren't being met during the meeting. | |||
<span>During the meeting:</span> | |||
<span></span> | |||
*Be mindful of participants who may not be able to see or hear or otherwise fully participate in virtual meetings. If an attendee is blind, you should use more descriptive language that paints a picture of what others are seeing and provides richer context. Some people use screen readers to access information. In this case, make sure your presentation has image descriptions and refrain from using images/GIFs with flashing lights as they can cause seizures, headaches, and migraines. If an attendee is deaf or hard of hearing, make sure you're using a platform that supports real-time closed captioning. | |||
*<span>Use a shared document for notetaking. Offline versions of meeting documents allows those joining by phone to participate better.</span> | |||
*Those who join a meeting over the phone do not have the same functions available as those using the desktop. A big concern is that people joining by phone cannot use the chat or get links posted on the chat, etc. Consider sending important links ahead of the meeting, or in your workspace during, so people on the phone can access them. | *Those who join a meeting over the phone do not have the same functions available as those using the desktop. A big concern is that people joining by phone cannot use the chat or get links posted on the chat, etc. Consider sending important links ahead of the meeting, or in your workspace during, so people on the phone can access them. | ||
*Not everyone knows how to type quickly, navigate a computer, or use the controls in a virtual meeting. It can be helpful to provide a tutorial before meetings or during meetings so folks can more easily follow along. | *Not everyone knows how to type quickly, navigate a computer, or use the controls in a virtual meeting. It can be helpful to provide a tutorial before meetings or during meetings so folks can more easily follow along.<br> | ||
*If the meeting is large, and too many participants want to speak, engage with a 'talking stack' such as leaving a star in the chat to indicate the desire for a speaking turn, or for those phoning in, provide a pause before returning to the talking stack to see if they have any points to add. | |||
*Consider that people who have good internet bandwidth have better connectivity quality for video and voice. Working with this may be as simple as suggesting the person turn their camera off for the fastest possible internet, but also simply remaining patient if their internet kicks out when speaking. If it comes to suggesting they leave their suggestions in the chat, read them out loud as soon as you are able. | *Consider that people who have good internet bandwidth have better connectivity quality for video and voice. Working with this may be as simple as suggesting the person turn their camera off for the fastest possible internet, but also simply remaining patient if their internet kicks out when speaking. If it comes to suggesting they leave their suggestions in the chat, read them out loud as soon as you are able. | ||
*Recognize some folks may have background activity that can't be avoided while attending a meeting. Try to be flexible when it comes to folks needing to attend to their living and meeting situation, especially when meetings are held during people's 'off' time. | *Recognize some folks may have background activity that can't be avoided while attending a meeting. Try to be flexible when it comes to folks needing to attend to their living and meeting situation, especially when meetings are held during people's 'off' time. | ||
*Avoid the use of jargon and acronyms. Always explain them for newer members who might not be familiar with 'insider language.' | |||
*Newer members may feel less inclined to speak up due to being unfamiliar with meeting conduct and the presence of existing relationships in the group. Encourage new members to contribute ideas using strategies that avoid calling them out if they aren't comfortable speaking yet, such as using an interactive powerpoint or allowing them to leave ideas in the chat that can be read out by the facilitator. | |||
*Remind of meeting expectations for those who are new or might have trouble remembering, such as when to turn off the mic and video, using the chat channel, etc. | |||
*Many platforms are not made with disability and neurodivergent needs in mind. Those who are blind, deaf, hard of hearing, or disabled are left out when accessibility needs are not anticipated before the meeting. For a more detailed explanation of meeting these needs, see https://rootedinrights.org/how-to-make-your-virtual-meetings-and-events-accessible-to-the-disability-community/ | *Many platforms are not made with disability and neurodivergent needs in mind. Those who are blind, deaf, hard of hearing, or disabled are left out when accessibility needs are not anticipated before the meeting. For a more detailed explanation of meeting these needs, see https://rootedinrights.org/how-to-make-your-virtual-meetings-and-events-accessible-to-the-disability-community/ | ||
*For information on how to deal with participants who are not engaging respectfully during the meeting, see our wiki page titled "how can we incorporate space watchers and holders into our group without veering into policing?" | |||
Closing and after the meeting: | |||
*Hold a check out question, but try to keep it simple. For example, "what's one word you would use to describe how you're feeling after today's meeting?" Or, "share a compliment about 1 attendee present at today's meeting!" | |||
*Send the notes and a meeting summary afterwards. Share the main items that were achieved, any major decisions or action items and a meeting recording if relevant. | |||
*Provide a channel for follow up questions, suggestions or comments. | |||
If you have any suggested revisions or additional resources to share related to the above content, please email them to kenzie@lehub.ca. | If you have any suggested revisions or additional resources to share related to the above content, please email them to kenzie@lehub.ca. | ||
<br>[[File:Creative commons.png|300px|link=https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/|center|frameless]] | <br>[[File:Creative commons.png|300px|link=https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/|center|frameless]] |
Revision as of 17:42, 27 July 2022
This page was created to support activists in making their spaces more accessible, to ensure everyone is welcome and encouraged to join the climate movement in whatever way they can! The information included comes from existing organizer databases and resources by movement thinkers. We've included resources from blogs written by people living with accessibility needs, as they are experts on this topic. Each personal experience is distinct, thus we encourage further insight from different positionalities on this topic. Several of the topics found in this guide are based on questions asked by activists in the HUB's community (i.e. how to make in-person events more accessible, how to make promotional materials more engaging etc.). This guide includes definitions of accessibility, considerations for accessible event and action planning, communication and content, creating an accessible culture and other suggestions related to creating a space that is inviting to all.
"Universal accessibility is the character of a product, process, service, information or environment which, with a view to fairness and an inclusive approach, allows anyone to carry out activities independently and to obtain equivalent results." - Groupe DÉFI Accessibilité (GDA) [1] & Ex Aequo
Ex Aequo distinguishes accessibility from adaptation:
- "Adaptation would consist of changes made in order to accommodate people in relation to “an environment, a communication, a program, or an already existing service.
- We adapt when we build a subway with only stairs, then add elevators several years later.
- We make it universally accessible when we provide access ramps to the buses."
Access Culture expands on the definition of accessibility, explaining:
"Spaces accessible to marginalized people – who are abused on many levels – embody openness, deliverance, freedom. An open space is an offered embrace. For people who live on the margins, who have to fight to prove their existence, who are excluded from movements, who are subject to abuse in the form of isolation, having access to spaces means having access to community, to connection, to existence.When we make spaces accessible, when we build movements based on inclusion, we recognize that each person has an intrinsic value, that our existence is beautiful and necessary. Creating accessible spaces is about recognizing that connection is necessary, that community is necessary, that our culture is built on the myth of separation, the lie of disconnection. We must move from independence to interdependence in order to transform society."
Accessibility in Event/Action Planning
Choice of Location
Universal Accessibility Collective suggests that in a universally accessible place, a person in a wheelchair can move around in all the rooms and access a toilet. [2]
Some of the further suggestions Sins Invalid offers based on your choice of location include [3] :
|
IMPORTANT: Take the necessary precautions according to the space in order to avoid accidents and prevent unfortunate situations in the event of an emergency.
Examples: remember to cover electrical wires, identify or cover slippery surfaces, ensure that outdoor spaces are well lit and that the identified emergency exits are functional.
Meeting Attendees Needs
Universal Accessibility Collective suggests:
|
Creating Space for Every Identity
Neurodivergent: Judy Singer, a sociologist who has autism, coined the term to describe how certain developmental disorders are normal variations in the brain, and people who have these features also have certain strengths. The neurodiverse umbrella includes but is not limited to ADHD, dyslexia, autism, and other learning disabilities. [4] Many include mental illnesses under the umbrella of neurodiversity too, such as but not limited to anxiety, bipolar, PTSD, schizophrenia etc. [5] Introversion: Where people who are extroverted are stimulated by their environment and absorb energy by interacting with others, introverted people recharge when they are alone and feel overwhelmed by prolonged social interactions as well as certain stimulations from their environment (noise, strong light etc). [6]
To ensure people who are neurodivergent [7] [8] and/or introverted [9] [10] feel comfortable coming to an event and expressing their concerns or needs:
|
According to UK Mutual Aid, there are things groups can do to ensure that people feel comfortable coming to an event and expressing their concerns in the context of racism [11] :
|
To ensure people feel comfortable coming to an event and expressing their concerns in the context of misogyny, sexism and transphobia [12] :
|
To ensure people feel comfortable coming to an event and expressing their concerns in the context of poverty or being low-income [13] :
|
Accessibility in Communications
There are many things to consider when it comes to accessible communication, from formatting to the language used. Accessible communication is extremely important. According to statistics from 2012, nearly half, about 49%, of people in what's colonially called Canada do not have sufficient literacy skills, and 55% do not have sufficient numeracy proficiency. Thus, it is important to ensure our written material is easy to read, easy to understand, easy to find the information you need and the information is easy to use the first time you read it.
General Guidelines for Accessible Written materials [14]
1. Write for your audience. Use language your audience understands. If you are targeting the general public, a rule of thumb is to aim for an 8th grade reading level or lower. Check out the following resourcewhich can be used to reduce the reading level of your writing. 2. Put the most important information at the beginning, bolded, and include background information (when necessary) toward the end. 3. Limit paragraphs/written sections to 3-8 lines, 5 being a happy medium. 4. Use as few words as possible to get your point across! (e.g. a number of vs 'some', in order to vs 'to'.). Remove 'filler' words such as descriptive words that do not add to your main idea. 5. Format information in lists, tables etc. to break up written text and add variety that is more visually appealing. Add headings if they'll help break information up. 6. Add blank space! This draws the eyes better to key written ideas. Especially around important ideas and to separate sections. 7. Avoid jargon, abbreviations and technical terms. Keep your language as simple as possible (e.g. disseminate vs 'send', in accordance with vs 'by'). See more examples of simplifying your language here.8. Bold important ideas! 9. Illustrate text with images when possible. 10. Ensure your language is gender-neutral.
|
Writing Image Descriptions [15]
Most important elements to describe:
Basic process for writing a description:
|
Tips for maximizing accessibility according to the specific type of online document are available using this resource.
|
Creating Accessible Group Cultures
The following section drew from the writings of:
- Liz Kessler, a person who describes themselves as disabled and who is involved in struggles for justice [18]
- Lee, a disabled, queer, trans and autistic activist. [19]
Practices that Foster Accessible Cultures Include...
Different abilities, different limits... work with them! Do not set standards for hard, or how much, work should be completed. |
Incorporate regular discussions about personal and group boundaries. This allows each person to give their consent actively and enthusiastically when they have the capacity to do so. This also promotes respect for these limits. Short term limits for long term sustainability. |
Accept people who are less reliable and do not depend on one person to hold an activity. Last-minute disengagement related to personal conditions or situations is common! Accept these contingencies and be interested in what the disengaged person needs to be able to pause or move forward. |
Do not overload the schedule. No need to follow the capitalist (and counter-intuitive) 9 to 5. |
Plan break times. Do not have meetings or tasks to complete during breaks. Commit to the entire team taking a break so no one feels excluded or singled out. |
Focus on the content (rather than how it's said). Some people will express ideas or comments while crying or angrily rather than using statements such as "I feel..." and "I think...". No matter how emotional the person is when sharing their ideas, what they have to say is of equal importance. |
Create communities that last beyond activism. When a person takes a break from activism, access to the support and social contact of the activist community encourages resilience. |
Listen to people who tell you what they need. Social norms are tailored to some identities more than others. If you feel comfortable in a space and other people tell you that you don't, it may be time to take action so that they too feel comfortable. |
Accept that accessibility is a process. There is no set finish line, we have to stay tuned and pay attention to the people around us. |
Understand intellectual privilege and recognize that there are many forms of intelligence. Emphasizing intellectualism reinforces that people should conform to one form of intelligence – that is, so-called intelligence as defined in white, bodily, elitists, and academic contexts. Recognize that there are many forms of intelligence, and that people are valuable regardless of their perceived intelligence. |
Not interpreting eye contact or body language. Ask to touch a person (even for a hug) and avoid imposing eye contact. |
Taking into account classism and internalized ableism. Asking about someone's occupation can create a feeling of exclusion for people with certain identities. Not everyone has the privilege that comes with having a 'good' job; social connection, higher income and sometimes health insurance. |
Deconstructing the Politics of Desire. The people who are most often 'front and center' in our communities enjoy white privilege, attractiveness (or body) privilege, able-bodied privilege, and class. |
Pay particular attention to intersectional perspectives. Intersectional perspectives are those of people who experience more than one social identity limiting their accessibility to spaces. |
Create habits related to accessibility. For example, the use of a planning list adapted to the current project or process helps team members to develop reflexes as to the accessibility aspects to consider when organizing an activity. UK Mutual Aid has developed a list specific to holding face-to-face, hybrid or online events which you can use to adopt specific practices in your teams. |
Holding Accessible Virtual Meetings
Tips from Aspiration Tech's Evelyn Arellano [20]
Before the meeting:
- Schedule group meetings at least 2-3 days ahead of time. This helps members to arrange for schedules, care-taking, quiet space, tech, etc.
- Provide context regarding the main agenda items before the meeting. For example, what is the main purpose and importance of the meeting? What are the meeting goals?
- Request input and feedback from all who will be participating to add agenda items and confirm whether the meeting goals address their needs. Make sure those attending are clear on how time will be spent.
- Ask participants to share if they will need translation, interpretation, or any other accommodations. Ask if those who plan to participate need any assistance in setting up and learning the technology platforms used. Provide at least a few days for participants to inform you about their needs.
- Provide items you want participants to review before or during the meeting ahead of time so folks can reflect before the meeting.
- Mention if you will be recording ahead of time so folks can raise concerns if they have them.
At the beginning of the meeting:
- Start with introductions and a check-in. Let folks introduce themselves, their pronouns and make time for relationship building by letting people share how they are doing or something about them. For example, check-in questions related to care might be "what colour best describes how you're feeling today?" Or, "If you're comfortable, share one high and one low from your week so far!" You can also hold more fun get-to-know one another check-in's to lighten the mood of the meeting, such as "tell us about a book or tv show you engaged with recently that you'd recommend!" Or, "what is your favourite houseplant?"
- It might be relevant to come up with and share participation guidelines and/or the group's mission statement to ground the group before beginning. Some examples of participation guidelines, inspired by Aspiration Tech [21] , might include...
- Please focus on listening, not only on what you are hearing.
- Wherever possible, please refrain from multitasking on email or social media. Try to stay tuned in to what others are saying and feeling.
- Please use simple, accessible language. Please avoid jargon and acronyms.
- When you speak, please try to make one point or a few brief points and then let others speak. We want everyone to have an equal chance to speak.
- Help us be mindful of the schedule and stay on time. Please support us in moving the dialog forward.
- 'Please indicate you want to speak by raising your hand on video; if you are not able to use or raise your hand, please feel free to speak up, but please try not to interrupt others.
- Stay muted when you are not speaking.
- Please be mindful of background noise and join the call from a quiet location if you can. Parents and caregivers are certainly exempt, but muting still applies.
- Try to take notes and video recordings for those who can't attend. Name it early that you are recording and allow folks to opt out, by getting off video, or managing their participation. Plans to record should also be mentioned before the meeting so concerns can be addressed.
- Provide a person or place where attendees can seek support if they feel disrespected or have needs that aren't being met during the meeting.
During the meeting:
- Be mindful of participants who may not be able to see or hear or otherwise fully participate in virtual meetings. If an attendee is blind, you should use more descriptive language that paints a picture of what others are seeing and provides richer context. Some people use screen readers to access information. In this case, make sure your presentation has image descriptions and refrain from using images/GIFs with flashing lights as they can cause seizures, headaches, and migraines. If an attendee is deaf or hard of hearing, make sure you're using a platform that supports real-time closed captioning.
- Use a shared document for notetaking. Offline versions of meeting documents allows those joining by phone to participate better.
- Those who join a meeting over the phone do not have the same functions available as those using the desktop. A big concern is that people joining by phone cannot use the chat or get links posted on the chat, etc. Consider sending important links ahead of the meeting, or in your workspace during, so people on the phone can access them.
- Not everyone knows how to type quickly, navigate a computer, or use the controls in a virtual meeting. It can be helpful to provide a tutorial before meetings or during meetings so folks can more easily follow along.
- If the meeting is large, and too many participants want to speak, engage with a 'talking stack' such as leaving a star in the chat to indicate the desire for a speaking turn, or for those phoning in, provide a pause before returning to the talking stack to see if they have any points to add.
- Consider that people who have good internet bandwidth have better connectivity quality for video and voice. Working with this may be as simple as suggesting the person turn their camera off for the fastest possible internet, but also simply remaining patient if their internet kicks out when speaking. If it comes to suggesting they leave their suggestions in the chat, read them out loud as soon as you are able.
- Recognize some folks may have background activity that can't be avoided while attending a meeting. Try to be flexible when it comes to folks needing to attend to their living and meeting situation, especially when meetings are held during people's 'off' time.
- Avoid the use of jargon and acronyms. Always explain them for newer members who might not be familiar with 'insider language.'
- Newer members may feel less inclined to speak up due to being unfamiliar with meeting conduct and the presence of existing relationships in the group. Encourage new members to contribute ideas using strategies that avoid calling them out if they aren't comfortable speaking yet, such as using an interactive powerpoint or allowing them to leave ideas in the chat that can be read out by the facilitator.
- Remind of meeting expectations for those who are new or might have trouble remembering, such as when to turn off the mic and video, using the chat channel, etc.
- Many platforms are not made with disability and neurodivergent needs in mind. Those who are blind, deaf, hard of hearing, or disabled are left out when accessibility needs are not anticipated before the meeting. For a more detailed explanation of meeting these needs, see https://rootedinrights.org/how-to-make-your-virtual-meetings-and-events-accessible-to-the-disability-community/
- For information on how to deal with participants who are not engaging respectfully during the meeting, see our wiki page titled "how can we incorporate space watchers and holders into our group without veering into policing?"
Closing and after the meeting:
- Hold a check out question, but try to keep it simple. For example, "what's one word you would use to describe how you're feeling after today's meeting?" Or, "share a compliment about 1 attendee present at today's meeting!"
- Send the notes and a meeting summary afterwards. Share the main items that were achieved, any major decisions or action items and a meeting recording if relevant.
- Provide a channel for follow up questions, suggestions or comments.
If you have any suggested revisions or additional resources to share related to the above content, please email them to kenzie@lehub.ca.
- ↑ Groupe DEFI Accessibilite (GDA) - Research report for associations in Montreal - Universal Accessibility and contributing designs (version 5.3), Langevin, Rocque, Chalghoumi & Ghorayeb, University of Montreal
- ↑ https://collectifau.ca/
- ↑ https://www.sinsinvalid.org/blog/access-suggestions-for-a-public-event
- ↑ https://www.webmd.com/add-adhd/features/what-is-neurodiversity
- ↑ https://www.instagram.com/p/CYBl-miPcCL/
- ↑ Cain, Susan. Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking, Brown Publishing Group, New York, 2012.
- ↑ https://accessculture.wordpress.com/2012/07/06/how-to-be-an-ally-to-disabled-neurodiverse-folks-in-activist-academic-communities/
- ↑ https://www.cs.jhu.edu/~misha/DIReadingSeminar/Papers/Hughes16.pdf
- ↑ The Invisible Students in the Classroom: How to Include the Introverts Without Excluding the Extroverts. MA thesis by Sharron Emilie Dow.
- ↑ https://thecatalystnews.com/2021/03/04/how-to-care-for-your-introvert/
- ↑ https://www.mutual-aid.co.uk/
- ↑ https://www.mutual-aid.co.uk/
- ↑ https://www.mutual-aid.co.uk/
- ↑ https://www.plainlanguage.gov/guidelines/
- ↑ https://antimonarchy.tumblr.com/post/635980711208386560/how-to-create-image-descriptions
- ↑ https://www.bdadyslexia.org.uk/advice/employers/creating-a-dyslexia-friendly-workplace/dyslexia-friendly-style-guide
- ↑ https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/
- ↑ https://data.over-blog-kiwi.com/1/85/65/14/20180525/ob_91a56c_milieu-militant-inclusif-neurodivergen.pdf
- ↑ https://accessculture.wordpress.com/2012/07/06/how-to-be-an-ally-to-disabled-neurodiverse-folks-in-activist-academic-communities/
- ↑ http://commonslibrary.org/power-dynamics-and-inclusion-in-virtual-meetings/
- ↑ http://commonslibrary.org/power-dynamics-and-inclusion-in-virtual-meetings/